The Starr Gate app takes more than just your total Pilot Score into account when calculating discounts. It also takes into account the number of flights and the recency of the flights which you have chosen to share.
The better your scores, the more often you fly, and the more recent your flights, the better the chance of receiving a better discount.
Remember, Starr Gate will never use your scores to make your insurance premiums go up. Starr Gate always offers pilots the best rate it can using the most current underwriting criteria.